Portnoy Reviews 'Paper Thin' Pie At Bayonne's The Vic Tavern

So thin you can get a paper cut on it.

Dave begins his trip to Staten Island at The Vic, where the box is so light there is potential for a great pie.

Photo Credit: One Bite Pizza Reviews

02/08/2024 8:57 a.m.

That's what Barstool Sports CEO Dave Portnoy had to say about the pie at The Vic Tavern, a family-owned restaurant on Hobart Avenue in Bayonne.

Portnoy stopped by apparently during a round of One Bite reviews across the river in Staten Island.

He said The Vic is "very cool" on the inside, with pizza "so light" and "paper thin."

He ultimately rated it a 7.7 saying if it had a slightly crispier crust, he'd give it an 8 or more.

Portnoy has famously been a friend to Al Santillo of Santillo's Pizzeria on S. Broad Street in Elizabeth, who suffered a fire last month.

Click here to follow Daily Voice Cresskill-Closter and receive free news updates.